Fuller Spurling

Call us:

01932 564098

Menu
  • Home
  • About us
    • People
      • Mark-Harvey-200×200Mark Harvey FCA – Partner
      • sue-keane-200×200Sue Keane FCA – Partner
      • Portrait of Amy Robins Fuller SpurlingAmy Robins LLB CTA ADIT – Partner
      • Consultant
      • Senior managers
        • David HodgsonDavid Hodgson FCCA
        • Photo of Philip Crowther-Green of Fuller Spurling Chartered AccountantsPhilip Crowther-Green
        • lana-ward-apr-2019-200×200Lana Ward
    • Offices
      • Fuller Spurling Chertsey officeChertsey Office
      • Fuller Spurling Sandhurst officeSandhurst Office
    • News
      • Budget 2021: live coverage and video review
      • Will IR35 be postponed again?
      • IR35 – where are we now?
    • About us
      General

      We give practical help and guidance whether you need help with your tax return or whether you run a business and need accounts, tax or VAT help and advice.

      Limited Companies and LLPs

      Whatever your size or industry sector we have the experience to be able to help and advise you. If you are a larger Limited Company or LLP then we can also carry out the statutory audit.

      FCA regulated entities

      If you run a business which is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority we can help lodge reports to the FCA (typically via “Gabrielle”) and carry out the statutory audit if required.

      Charities

      We help charities prepare accounts and carry out Independent Examinations of Charity accounts or audits of the accounts of larger Charities.

      Solicitors

      We help prepare accounts and carry out Audits as required by the Law Society

    • Close
  • Accounting
    • Accounts & Auditing
    • Bookkeeping
    • Our Online Accounting Services
    • Close
  • Tax
    • Tax Compliance
    • Tax & VAT Enquiry Fee Protection Service
    • Tax Investigations and enquiries
    • Tax Planning
    • VAT
    • Reverse Charge Rules for Builders and Related Trades
    • Close
  • Specialist
    • Business Advisory
    • Charities
    • Company Secretarial
    • Contracts for self employed
    • ICAEW Business Advice Service
    • IR35 Contractors
    • Payroll
    • Tax & VAT Enquiry Fee Protection Service
    • Close
  • Land & Property
    • Inheritance Tax
      • Family Investment Company
      • Inheritance Tax and the Family Home
      • Property Trading Companies and Business Property Relief Case Law
    • Buying a property
      • Property Incorporation vs Ownership
    • Selling a property (Capital Gains Tax)
      • Capital Gains Tax – new payment deadline for residential sales
      • Changes to CGT, PPR and lettings relief – April 2020
      • CGT and Rebasing Explained
      • CGT Dates for Different Property Sales
    • Close
  • Making Tax Digital
    • MTD for VAT
    • Close
  • News
  • Contact Us
Home » Property Trading Companies and Business Property Relief Case Law

Property Trading Companies and Business Property Relief Case Law

This article examines the challenges HMRC have raised for land and property based businesses via the courts in recent years and the ‘trading’ requirements that must be met.

Furnished holiday letting companies, serviced offices and the provision of short term accommodation in the form of hotels are examples of businesses which have been previously accepted as qualifying as a trade by HMRC in relation to the application of Business Property Relief (‘BPR’).

  • BPR provides relief from Inheritance tax at 50% or 100%
  • There is no BPR if the business is regarded as non-trading and carrying out investment activities only.

This article focuses on the developments in case law relating to serviced accommodation and holiday lettings, however, there have been similar principles established for BPR claims for farming and estates businesses.

‘Investment’ or ‘Trading?’

The tests originating from case law around 20 years ago established that the activities of a business must be examined in a quantitative fashion to determine whether its overall activities related to trading, as opposed to investment. The trading element of the business should constitute 50% or more of the business activity to qualify for BPR and the investment elements of the business should remain at the lower level.

This was determined by looking at the level of income and profit the business achieved from its activities, time spent by each member of staff, where the original capital had been invested and ongoing continuing investment, and the overall nature of the business in looking at whether it could be seen as primarily ‘making or holding investments’ or a conscious effort to pursue a trade for the purposes of realising a profit.

Where is the Trade?

In recent years HMRC have challenged property trading businesses on the basis that the level of services provided was low. Without a significant level of services provided alongside the provision of rental accommodation, HMRC can argue that the business is primarily an investment activity in nature which would not qualify for BPR.

As the trade lies within the services provided, it is important to demonstrate on paper and in practice that the business provides these services to the required scale. A furnished holiday letting business could for example demonstrate that its clients are offered an ‘all round service’ such as; laundry and cleaning services, reception services, food and drinks or a café on site, television and phone services, excursions and entertainment (i.e. evening activities in the café or bar area). Simply providing referral services for these services is not sufficient.

The approach by HMRC has been to consider businesses ‘in the round’ and to adopt a more qualitative test looking at the nature of the business. This places the taxpayer at a far greater burden to demonstrate that the trading side of the business significantly outweighs the investment side (which relates to the simple provision of accommodation in its simple form).

Some Practical Points . . .

It is important to remember that different standards of ‘trading’ exist in established case law for lifetime taxes (Capital Gains Tax for example) and for death taxes, relevant to BPR. One should never presume that HMRC will seek to agree a position for BPR on the basis that they have accepted previous claims for trading in a taxpayer’s lifetime.

Would you like help and advice on this or any other tax issue?
Speak to one of our tax specialists today to consider how business planning can be considered at this stage to safeguard the tax reliefs available.

To make an appointment to speak with one of our specialists please telephone 01932 564098 or email us using our ‘Contact Us’ page.

This article was published in June 2018 – please be aware that the information above may have changed in subsequent months. This note is written for the general interest of our clients and is not a substitute for consulting the relevant legislation or for taking professional advice.

What’s your question?

Call 01932 564098

Recent News

  • Budget 2021: live coverage and video review
  • Protected: Will IR35 be postponed again?
  • IR35 – where are we now?
  • VAT reverse charge for the construction industry
  • Coronavirus Business Support Guide

News Categories

  • Articles
  • Case Study
  • Company Law
  • Opinion
  • Tax
  • Tax Q&As
  • Testimonial
  • Updates
  • VAT Q&As

Follow us

Client Zone

Latest news & posts

  • Budget 2021: live coverage and video review 1st March 2021
  • Protected: Will IR35 be postponed again? 18th February 2021
  • IR35 – where are we now? 5th February 2021
  • VAT reverse charge for the construction industry 1st February 2021
  • Coronavirus Business Support Guide 8th January 2021

Legal etc

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Fuller Harvey Ltd
Registered in England No: 3881540

© 2010–2021 Fuller Spurling - Chartered Accountants · Site by Powerhut · Built on the Genesis Framework